Navigating the Maze: Understanding PBAC, ABAC, and RBAC in Identity Access Management

In the ever-evolving landscape of cybersecurity, Identity Access Management (IAM) plays a pivotal role in safeguarding sensitive information and ensuring that the right individuals have the right level of access. Three prominent models – Policy-Based Access Control (PBAC), Attribute-Based Access Control (ABAC), and Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) – have emerged as cornerstones in the realm of IAM. In this article, we will explore the key differences between these models and their unique approaches to access control.


Role-Based Access Control (RBAC):

RBAC is one of the traditional models for access control, organizing permissions based on job responsibilities. Users are assigned specific roles, and each role is associated with a set of permissions. This simplifies administration, as access rights are granted based on job function rather than individual attributes. However, the rigid structure of RBAC may lead to over-permissioning, where users have more access than necessary.


Key characteristics of RBAC include:


  • Roles: Users are assigned roles based on their job responsibilities.
  • Permission Sets: Each role is associated with a predefined set of permissions.
  • Scalability: RBAC is easy to scale as it aligns with organizational hierarchies.


Attribute-Based Access Control (ABAC):

ABAC takes a more dynamic and flexible approach to access control by considering various attributes associated with users, resources, and the environment. Access decisions are based on evaluating these attributes against policies defined by the organization. ABAC is particularly effective in dynamic environments where access requirements are contingent on multiple factors.


Key characteristics of ABAC include:


  • Attributes: Access decisions are made based on user, resource, and environmental attributes.
  • Context-Aware: ABAC considers a dynamic context, allowing for fine-grained control.
  • Flexibility: Policies can be defined based on a wide range of attributes, enabling precise access control.


Policy-Based Access Control (PBAC):

PBAC is a model that emphasizes the use of policies to determine access. Policies are rules or conditions that govern access to resources. Unlike RBAC, PBAC and ABAC can work in tandem. PBAC allows for the creation of detailed policies that can take into account user roles, attributes, and other contextual information.


Key characteristics of PBAC include:


  • Policy-Centric: Access is determined by policies defined by administrators.
  • Granularity: Policies can be finely tuned to specific scenarios or conditions.
  • Adaptability: PBAC allows for the adaptation of access control rules as organizational needs evolve.




Choosing the right access control model is crucial for organizations to strike a balance between security and operational efficiency. While RBAC provides a structured approach based on roles, ABAC offers dynamic and context-aware control, and PBAC combines the strengths of both. The choice often depends on the specific needs and nature of the organization. In today’s dynamic and interconnected digital landscape, a nuanced understanding of PBAC, ABAC, and RBAC is indispensable for effective Identity Access Management.



If you’ve found this interesting, join us for a free webinar and Q&A with KuppingerCole on Nov 30, 2023 at 10:00 AM (EST).